~vt^-NV~NmS{_00gя1gf[RYec{:N~vt^-NVSQNz-NV~vt^~NmSv`tSS}Ybaba6ePgeQYNzvQ。O_YZPe.sv[^。ONN__`N勔^AQdkNV:NkwZPtxvzeze.sYN0:NN/}yofPge{QNNNS{_NN。OgtQNywZfn~NmS0000Zfn~NmSggv/fYNQ*N0,{N*N/fZfn~NmSU。vrQgN:NZfn~Nmv^N/fN*N*gSU。~Nm/f(WW^-NgvS_SvSYD,g;NINbFUND,g;NINvQb_`vS_cя-NV 80 t^N)n]_lYmSNYm_lQg-Nv*NSOTyN~Nm0,{N*NN-NVT'kASkQAS]NN~~NmSU。vkgsQ_NNS_elVTV~Nm6R^v]+RgsQ1。/f:NNHN-NV~NmSU。O'Y'Y=_e'k:NNHN-NVvSYD,g;NINNSU。0RsND,g;NIN0,{N*NvN*NVT{/f^V;NINvOeuO-NVNNSYD,g;NINSU。0RsND,g;NIN0*NVT{N{w0RvSeegw[hQN&{TS[00000N*NvT{HhgsQv1。/f[ZfnmRRvN0{w0RvDe>f:ymRR/f*N1Y%v]NSRvQ1Y%N(We^V;NINvOeu/f(We?e^v0V[:gO;NIN0(uVgONve_cR]NS|b@gNyN1uONvSU。00NTsabSpeKNvsQ|~g。ONNGP[}SSNSN(uN*N~~SevFhg0`vO0W_vNQQv)YSOLNvOe_vNQQv_6qO^8^NN7h00N1Q0YgNf。o(Wv[RgFhgvGPON:NX[(WN*NlgtFhgv~[SSRSO{fvONN_lgzNRvRgFhg1YS[RgFhgv+RTyb$RRVdkSOSS?S_^8^;N0N0Zfnv~NmSS000Zfn~NmSggv/fYNQ*N0,{N*N/fZfn~NmSU。vrQ0gN:NZfn~Nmv^N/fN*N*gSU。~Nm/f(WW^-NgvS_SvSYD,g;NINbFUND,g;NINvQb_`vS_cя-NV 80 t^N)n]_lYmSNYm_lQg-Nv*NSOTyN~Nm0,{N*NN-NVT'kASkQAS]NN~~NmSU。vkgsQ_NNS_elVTV~Nm6R^v]+RgsQ1。/f:NNHN-NV~NmSU。O'Y'Y=_e'k:NNHN-NVvSYD,g;NINNSU。0RsND,g;NIN0,{N*NvN*NVT{/f^V;NINvOeuO-NVNNSYD,g;NINSU。0RsND,g;NIN0*NVT{N{w0RvSeegw[hQN&{TS[00 N*NvT{HhgsQv1。/f[ZfnmRRvN0{w0RvDe>f:ymRR/f*N1Y%v]NSRvQ1Y%N(We^V;NINvOeu/f(We?e^v0V[:gO;NIN0(uVgONve_cR]NS|b@gNyN1uONvSU。00N1Q0YgNf。o(Wv[RgFhgvGPON:NX[(WN*NlgtFhgv~[SSRSO{fvONN_lgzNRvRgFhg1YS[RgFhgv+RTyb$RRVdkSOSS?S_^8^;N00001.1-NVvSYD,g;NIN (bFUND,g;NIN)00-NVvSYD,g;NIN/fcWG-NuNg~m9Tv;mRTFUN;mR-NR]vSU。FO/fyR]lg(WVuN'`v6R :ghVT]wQvLNRm_NNS(WSfR e:ghVv;mR-NRmVdkSYD,g;NINNSU。0RяN]ND,g;NIN0000;xSYD,g;NINT]ND,g;NINSU。vsQ.V }/fng+gt^v=_v?el~Nm6R^0ngNv1996MbgN)Rl(9~z`, 1999NwS,{Nzpp73-75)dkMRNSfR N_0RFUNSv6eeQVdkR]NNSN(Wb/gSf-NRmVO-NVv_Y]Nb/g。PYu(W6kNb_b'Y!jFUNSuN0cgq Mokyr(1990,pp.235-50) v}VvN)Rlv[elVv?e^VYRyb6R^vO'`/fV]NSklVp(WMRbvSV0NcQgJSpeveb/g(WVN/f`N)RlOb/f`ObyNONiRYOCgvnflegOb01uON6R^ (yNONRlQN?e^ybQ) SN(uyNONviRYO6evCgTiRYOc6RCg[ON;NvSfR SON[;mRc[NVdkSNOyvc[Nb,ggv;mRwSeQNNSTR]NMQvc[NvNf9(uVeb/gev{telSNSb'Y!jFUNSuN0000c9cknv} (Fairbank,1992,p179),0ng+gt^v-NV?e^WeNNR'Y!jg~~v;mRSb?elQNON'YW]FUNb/gSf0vkpgI{'YWuN;mR?e^We-NVNFOlg~>y1u_Nlg1uON0NUO'YWuN;mR/fNS(WlgN[^vyrksQ|SybQTvbNSU。wegv (9ckn1999,NwSp.19)0v^NFO[N,~vYv"Nu}Tgu@gN:YvCgRNSNN~[$Rbl'Yいv[NSY{kNN (9ckn,{Nz[ey^NwSp29 _Op,{Nz``vSST~eRNwSp345QReh-NVZfnS 1800-1900t^-NV>yyQHr>y1993) yr+R/f[^1ue[S?e^v0WN?el;mRvOea%Ny_Nq_T0R1uONvSU。0(Wy6R^N'YWyNONegObON[``Tw"NvmuNLN-NvR]S_6qNSSU。wegRN19060t^MRlgN)R6R^@bNNb/gSfb/g(WVuN;mR-Nv'Y!jFUNS^(u:Nyr_v]ND,g;NINNSSU。weg0000ngvSYD,g;NIN/f^。eS_N~Nmf[[@byvOWD,g;NINvQyrp/f?e^)R(uvQ?elWeyrCgBlvQy)RN`_c[>yO)Rv0kY?e^)R(uvN[%[zv[~ NlN)R0lgbzyNONvRlQ6RyNONgCg[vvbybQ?e^_N)R(uvQNaOryNON"NvyrCgNN[^R~vFUNY"}STy)Rv (9ckn1993.p19)0y[FUR~/fOWD,g;NINvSNyr_ckY Landes(1998,p222) @byOWD,g;NIN bNeHesv6eeQRMNlQte*N~Nm;N/f:N[^TyrCg6~uNV^:Wr。R]NSRmuNRNSc0Landes:N18 N~vlV_N/f7hN*N6eeQRMNlQ[FUR~vOWD,g;NIN>yO0S_evV/f*NzllQs^6eeQRMklQs^-NN6~gvS_-pNRte*N~Nm:Ns^luNv}YD,g;NIN>yOVdkS_eVv^:W['YelV (}6qNSTVW。elV)R]SNRmNGW6eeQklV30Ųmokyr,1993,p.56)9ckn (1993,p24)}Nn+gz6ev^6R^SNfSN[Nv/}z6e6R ([TgCgRvNNvzsNO6R^Sv*alL?S[FUR~vL (sQengbzON[^yrv6R^S[FUsQ|T?e^[NN~Nm;mRvWe9ckn1993,pp19-20SUOphHo Ping-ti,1962,The ladder of success in imprinal China: aspects of social mobility, 1368-1911, New York,Columbia Univeristy Press)0000/f:NNHNlVvOWD,g;NIN__1。'Yi}TcngvOWD,g;NINtSSN^kU_ebT_YSSf[[。dkR_~N'k2mNNN0Wt?el~gv]+RvQ-NggTv/fBaechler (1976,p.79) vT0D,g;NINSU。vg9h,gnl/fTNeSN?elvN~NS?elYCQS00'k2mv?elN~NR NNye_:_?e^NN?eV{ObsQzvFU;NINNKNNUSeb1u8feNN?eV{>e_ObsQzNSn>e_`yrWeyrCg_z6ev6R^ (Mokyr 1993,p.44,north,1981,pp158-68)0S_evn?e^Y(WFU;NINKNMRv?eV{`~4ls^NIYLsQVQbFUvNN?eV{0(Wl_6R^ebS_ev-NVNFOlgnfl-NvlQs^Sl1uHhO(WSllQckagNNSb_bl_vi_NlgN-NVl_6R^{|yO-NzlVN_yrCg6~NNzs^GWzsNOeS_eVvs^GWzs0VIQci}T_v}YD,g;NIN>yO-Nzs[@bgNN7hN1ulaNh:gsQQ[?e^lgrzeOv"Cg@bN?e^z6eRg:_(Landes,1998)0-NVng+gt^vOWD,g;NINNlVvOWD,g;NINN7hz6RNlQyrCg6~N_NOvzs1ue?e^CgRlgla/ecvTl'`@bNSIYL@bgbRvN6R?e^gbLve{_?eV{?e^vz6eR_]lg:_'YvlQqQ"?eVdklQW^lQqQeI{lQqQNNQNN[hQlg6R^Sv"?e/ec0/f:NNHN,{Nybng[XTQVe`S'klQqQ"NSN(uegZPYdkKNYvlQqQeTU>N0000n?e^vRNONhs(W*Ys^)YVbNMR_SU。wegvSё6R0Sё6R{|yO~g0}0N2mxvzBg_0wS24,{1g (1964) ) 0yQQg~Nmv>fWyrp/fQlv;Nm9/f]uNvg。R-^:W@bNQNuNN/fNNST:NN^:WSL (R]4ls^NO) QNN_。gNNuNNy,4lgv'k_Q7bf。g'Y!jǖ]LNNSFUNSuNvQ:W0000Nhg。QI{:NNhvERge.s (OYYang, 2001)cQ~NmvSU。/fN*NR]ovz0S_~Nm6R^=_ONfHesNONe>yO1。O(W~r`elgQNT]NKNvR]k*N6qN~uNTyNT0WNfHesv9e~v6qN1。ORS:NNNQlTN]NVOuNRc0yR]ovRR/fNagNv9eU6R^v9eNSW^vSU。0_Yf[cQN/fiRYOQNT[W^Nu/fW^SMb[NNQNTNNuNTyVQN:ghvNTvQsVOQNuNRciRYOQNTXR0000@bNng+gt^QNv=_/f?e^v:gO;NINL:NTlgObN)RTONyN"Nv6R^ bvN/fW0Wyg6RTYV]NveQO b0ng+gt^vW0W6R^]vS_S1887t^nNv[eW0WU_fNSSTn2mdNyNl0uYg'Ye0uo。0uTv^[N/fOr"NTbNv_g00RNAS]NN~_g[yN0WNvObN%N;Nhs(W[y0uTyrCg6~0uKzsv]+R0SY[eTv^N6qgN~Slz^Nabl0uNTvQN"NvyrCg_NS?e^gROr"Nv0iRYOCg0}6q?e^(WTs^Tt'`ev^N~8^(udkyyrCg0yrCg6~N~8^(udkyyrCgvnc/fO`Or"N:_bv`v^TW0WvRv^000Nf>fVW0W@bgCgRMk'ks^GW0_。g[T[~g[eofvWeFUNbgNNNW0WvOP[0'Y~g50 vQ7b:NCOQTRQ'^0Wy]QskNsё0Wy:N0WNv5-10%vS_csNV[-N^:Wv'^0Wy4ls^0[ir0Wy~`S6ebv 50 (9~z`,{Nz1870-19110Zfn^Vv~NmR9cknR^1993NwS) yRb0Wy6R^f~Nmf[[f:NN)Re~NmSU。v6R^V:NCOQlg_0RNvRRNuvhQ萹E6evuNyg'`S0RSbQ0FO/f1970t^NSU。wegvD~Nmf[f(WKm^QlRRz^vNf9(u_NuNgNnx['`ebNOgΘiRbTcoRvOQzS_NONQseNRbΘiQS0W;NN^[CO7bg_'Y`ZFONcOoRQNNe0W;N1。^`ZCO7b0S_COQv]。ORR_Km^uN-NvΘi_eRb0Wy1。/fN$NQzvggHebw0Vdk(WN*N1uQY~6R^-NSNuvRb0Wy6R^/fygHesvW0W6R^ ( Stiglitz 1977, _N8^1976, _N8^SsN^dRb0Wy6RvW0W9ei[~NmSU。vbq_Tv~nc)09~z`(WMR_e-NcQ-NVvW0W@bgCgvR^v^NkS_evVf-NFO/fn+gyrCg6~T?e^Or"NvyrCgS/fW0W^:WNSvN*NSV0=。{lSvW0WpNVSTyA_nfMFOl_v^NgHe0WObW0WygCg(WyApNVS-NNSOrObW0WNCgvl_6R^_NSOYgCgNSNNV]VSW0WvCg)R/fNylg~{|yOOiQ。]NSlW bvNN0_N/f>yON[[vN*NSV09~z` (pp.73-83) cQn+g?e^6R^v=_ b(ueONSlgblI{cNfHesvlQqQ_/e'Y'YNOe'kV[/fS_eng~Nm=_vN*N;NSV01ueYVONgv[}YvYV6R^Tag~ObvQCg)R-NV?e^lgOb,gVONyN"Nvl_6R^@bN-NVyNONvnxgb4NNs^I{vzNvFONs^I{v9hnN/fYVON/f,gV?e^v=_6R^0000g_{N~9ckn (1993,NwS ,{5z)_-N~ (1993NwS,{2z) [Ns^I{ag~0YVOeuTyLu6R^vNN[VQN*Yq`v0HQng+gt^_Yn?e^NYVvQz(W_'Yz^N/fn?e^SvQvQ-NINTVNN/f*NxQWvOP[0NNNvof/fHay*YTGSNlQ:NrjL:NVbTVTQr^mHay*YTrNNjLevQsQ.V }/fNsQeYVN/ecIQ~^Yv O@bo`@bNdkNN[(N/fHayGSIQ~^9ei_1YSN_T~lTl'`qS:gvfSN/f{USvYVNOeu-NV0Vdk{|NN[~NmSU。vbq_T_NN{USR_~:N^V;NINOeu[-NV~NmSU。vbq_T0000ngNYVQzNuvag~6RvQ[[-NV~NmgvQckbq_T0ag~6Rbevlli_T[8nbR(WSRKNs^I{NNvi__eQ-NVOn?e^1YSNvQNSP6Rv?e^yrCg0WMOyr+R/fag~6R^Sb4xN[e[FUNvWeT[yFUvNaO:YBln?e^。z6e6R^lQs^TfS0V[N$RCgvBl(WS_eagNN_NgvQekaIN0S_ev-NVN/fN*NllV[lgVvN$RCgRVNlTFUN(W-NV9h,glgN[hQSSllQckvO0V(WyLuSkl0W/nv^N/f1u?e^Sl/f1urze?e^TJTSerzv;N1u,g0WN~bvj[V[gjej/fnflNTe'k2m'YFT-NVbelv0We0S_6qNlQckVNBlvN"N[hQOSSlrzlQckvO_N^eN-NVNFO/fngv;NCgbMRVN_NSNS0RVN^gvCg)RN0yLuVNv0WelrzTlQckvSlWY6R^_Nvnx`S-NVN0-NVvVlZQqQNZQYeONXf~O`yLuvN$RCgObvQNCg0V(W-NVvyLuW,g[L0WelN/f1uV?e^/f1uyLuE。lQv0We:ggltyLu0FOg>N0Wel:gg (^?e@。) Cg)RvN1ue>Nl["NTNzbNyDy1uON1u1uONbzRlQI{i7h[(W/f[-NVvSU。g_'YckbaIN0S`(Wi}TRqNSu_yLuv6R^v^lg-NVN|~0Wf[`N09ckn(WMR_e-N}NVN(WyLuvOPN6R^R1u~>y6R^`7h(uegKQg-NVN>yO[lQqQNRv{t,)YuvMQ9-dfv_`0000NyLugsQv/f-NVvwmsQ6R^0Sv_YSfNcyngVSVvnc/f。wmsQCg)RNYNvQ[yc#/fNQnxv?el[ O0n+gwmsQ}1uVNk_{tFON/f。O:Nn?e^vǖXTLONvLCg0Nv{tNFOO-NVwmsQsNSNOwmsQb:NggHesg。*alvng[P:gg0NONag~6R^[sQzsvP6RVON1u8fSlQs^z6eN_NON(ugHesv{tT6R^:Nng?e^cON'Yz6e0R^N:Nk_{twmsQvg'Y!.s/fON-NVFUNvSU。。g~NngPŸR^N*[[wmsQvpbqN (R^N1993,9cknNwS,{ASz:_R[/gevb/gpp566-570)0N0lV~NmS (1912-1949)0002.1e?el~Nmf[V[~Nmf[T[?e~Nmf[SV[6R^[~NmSU。vq_T00xvzlV~NmSvp/fNS_Ne?el~Nmf[0V[~Nmf[T[?e~Nmf[gsQv{KN/fV[6R^[~NmSU。vq_T0gяV[~Nmf[vck_pef[!jW (NgKQLi, 2001t^) 。^e (Hobbs,1651) gsQV[v``pef[SN0gTv^eNgGP:N(WlgV[6R^ek*NN/fvQN*NNvLeNN`=。RlwPbN[v"N_N`=。RlN+RNwPb(WylgV[6R^vagNN'YDn(ueNNwPbT2bkwPbv;mRVdkuN;mRNSSwegwPb(W~bNvVSOKNSue1。/fbN0cgqNgKQv!jWS_sCgQse[z6e (%NyO)Rv (@bV[:gO;NIN) en+gv~NmSU。v=_T。Pn1。SuNS_V[:gO;NINO?eCg1YSTl'`VO:_'YTl~NvV[fR)]nelVRt^v>yORqN1。SuNN bNfHesNONR]SU。uNRekba000NV[Rv$N_NQ0/f'k2m~NmSU。_vRVFOvQNN1。/fbqN~ (NASt^bN~vt^bN$N!kNLu'Yb) 0V(uT6R^NCgRznfl[lSl (VOzvbelS~S_z_bRb:N[T^l) T(u[l%Nf_yr+RS50VN(WrzbN_T]KNNSuQmb_'YSV_N/fVNlt2mkl0We[L0Wel。T]OT][lvL:N:Nrz_vVgb?ehzNo}Yi7h0000lV~NmSR:NV*N6klR[s[?ev6k(1911-1915), Qmbeg (1916-1927) ~NmSU。vёeg (1928-1938) , SbbTVqQQb(1938-1949)eg0000O[pg@b0NASN~R-NV?el9eiΘnon+gz[RS0/f,gW。OsQez[N~NmSU。T-NVFUN6~bvsQ|vpgQW。O0 dkfN=。0W}Nng+gt^-NVvFUN/f-NVz[Rg:_'YvcRRKNN[0(WcRz[z-NT~FUOb_bQv^nf[OV_FUOvlTl;N{t0(WYz[lQOI{~~-NFUN`Sf>fOR0 FUNN0R0Ne-NVKN?elsaRNNlQSKN'`(gNv[_N0NlQS^(W[hQllVKNN*g1uSEe/ctQ[NKNsQ.(Wez[nxzllP6R?eCgOlCgeg9eo?elsXN?el~~0 (l_O[pg) 0 ~HQu(W0N&GrbN0RNVR0NfN-N_N_ _KN:NngS_@。0FOg_FUKN?eebFUKNl00FUKN[?eseN00S_ey~[TzN6R9h,gNSl_v6R~Sgl6Rlgll0T;N06qNSCgKNY00[XT8nLN)R~KN-N00000FUN(WcRn+gv6R^9ei-NNFO[ev6R^vQswN。O(uN[vQ[LwWsQ.。O(u0ng[^Yz[_FUN(WTw@。-NNekcR[?evSU。O@。b:Nrze?e^vwckOzb_0hQVD?ebvN~R]NsNO6R^{|e_vQrz"Cg。"?e{8hQc7790N$N0(WT0Wv@。-NFUNNcQNNN[YNNRCg)RvBlS[/eNN~:ggTavTyYV:PR0ySU。b_TcQN{|mTOv>mKNvNv[g_IQci}T~bkT>m~ebqQbNObNCgybk?el[(uZTqQTQ6ROl;N?eZQlQs^zN。O:NRM?elCgRv8nbR0VNvlgbe[lFOtS/f[?evRYVvQ[?e8nbR/fgΑTe@bTvNNL:NQROYN[_?el[[Ye[NL:NQR/fNSR?el8nbv@。-NN[lQO)RvTS_QRvNNW,gqQ:NW@x00NqQ[0NHN:N[00NHN:N0gNNaONTab_`N7hvT[evL:N'Y[g{|yOvS[ (Saction) T`Zv`^0sSOwPNvN/f]v?QP[_NNNy)RS[>yOTSl:gsQ[?QP[L`Z0000n+glR-NVv?elNirv^lgb_byqQVdk[?ev^lgZW[vS_qQvW@x0@bN[lRv^N/f-NV?el[vL:NQR0OYY[-Nq。(W]g:gOcCge1。gR9T;`~6R(W]l:gOcCge1。9TQ6R(W]QN[R:_'Ye (blbN_) 1。/ec-N.YCg6RTfkR~N(W]QR1_。e (1915t^eVOYOe) 1。/ecTwl0Y[-Nq。(WΑeS[N6RNeQN[R'YN1。_YQ?e?e (N6RvSN-Nl) hsNNQNlQ_N>yO)Rv:NbT。8nbR/fN]v?eZQ)Rv:Nb?el8nbRvhQ0000NQf/fxQWv:gO;NIN(WNTngNCge1。S[T;Nz[PTeOrNlCg)Rv$N1。SQ0S_NvlQqQbtT[?e~Nmf[cQSNuX[NSv[?e8nbR_{n!j|b~vSRSR/fN{@。-NN(WNHN0WMO (/fXTf/f。wP/f(Wg/f(WΑ) :N8nbRlQs^0Y[-Nq。NQSvQNQN]v)Rv:Nb8nbRvhQ (@bA。c%c) NwS7hbv8nbR/fNSuX[NSv0NSvb]NSvL:N1。Sb:NNN8nbRgb?eZQbP6R?e^CgRvL:N_Ng:gOSbNN8nbRuX[NSNRNy)R:Nvhbv8nbR/fNSSR8nbTecS0SgTeTav8nbRMbSSb[?e8nbRAm ONS0000Vdk[?ez-NSR8nbTegwxvlQ_(W_-Ngb:。(WbTu[8nbReNS!j|b~vSR0SR(uOeg1。/fR|vNT,{N*Nb|vNN/fTNN0ckY]8YVY]v/flgNOvN7hSg,{NN (Slrze1u) MbgNNOgvlQck$Re0000lRv[?e1Y%_NR_~:NSN6R6R^[NNvS__vk[0NQNbKbk0Wr/fV:NSv~JTNlgCgRvNvQCg)RSgCgvNNaO:YNaNSvNV~lkl0Wv~NNv"NCg)R(WN1YS?elCgR__N_[hQ0@bNlRgb?eL:NNN[8nbRvgS[ENuv8nbRKNNuNv`'`_sNeNv`'`_s_Yb_b>yOeV0R0^eNg06q_e(WgFgP[Q?eCgvRNNusCgbvQNr1。/fNSMQvN0 FO/fQmbeg_N/f-NV``Lug;mveg00Qmb_NNuN{|yO;NIN``YuNNNNN)ReOb"NCgv`0OYW0Wl[Q[yёv^:W6R^TS_NNv"NCg*jRr^m0 ( Feuerwerker1983pp.85)00NNL?el_NgOr"Nv>yO;NINri_0[lIHhTvQNzl_NYuNlV_o;NINvu0Mokyr (1990,1993) T Landers(1998) fNl_6R^-Nvo;NINri_[g~NmSU。gbq_T0Y[-Nq。YuNvNN>yO;NINab_`(Wl_6R^-Nvub:N_eg'YFTS~nW0W9eiR-NOr"NTTyNS_L:Nvxy9h0000Vl?e^cR[?evRRe,gONSbN@bSbeFO/fyRRv^*g[hQ。Pbk;Nhs(WbbegVlS?eOT0WeS?eOv>NT。O0VlS?eOSbN@bg;NS[ZQ (SbklN(WQvqQNZQ) 01942t^'YRS?eXTS1ut6R9e:N>N6R0000-NVgv[?eSU。/f 1946 t^-NNSlV[lvwITTZQ>m[[?e8nbRvNNz0!k[?ezSN!kN1Y%JT~0vQ;NSVdVqQ$NZQv:gO;NINL:N;N/fqQNZQZWcN~>N(uTT?e^e_。[MOCQ(W;NZQ>mKNtR[?e$RvvQN;NSR;N _(WQV[Sz[>N_Mb1uQv?eZQQ[?e^LMOvRM0VlZQlgSn!j|b~SRvLR[]vCgR。OQSOvP6RNb_qQNZQ[lQs^8nbRvO_0;N。PV?e^1ueNVlZQsQ|*Yя_NOqQNZQ[。P/f&TS%c-N'`v,{NNRlgEQRO_RNqQNZQ,gv:gO;NINL:N[~vt^-NVgg^gv[?ez[hQ1Y񚕐VqQQb_Y_(Wlg;NS[ZQqQNZQSRv`QN?e^GrbS_V'Y[l[^L[_NhzNN*N:gO;NINvi7h0 1949 t^_qQNZQS(Wcd;NS[ZQVlZQv`QNGrb6R[QN!kYNy:gO;NINL:N00002.3lV~NmSU。hs00$N*N;Nrze[ev[lV~NmSU。v0O Liu Ta-chung and Yeh Kung-chia (1965) T][q。 (1947)0lVegv~NmSU。'YSR:NQNsN]FUNSq_TNfHesvNNTёNQ*NReg0 ;`SOSf[[NW,gTa1912-1949t^-NVv;`NQXR_^8^baNGW6eeQQNNlgXFO_NlgNMFO1937-1949t^vbNgNGWNQTNGW6eeQS/f>fWNM000019N~+gQsv!jN。v]NSNgvS_SvXFOtSq_TgP00RRR]TLN~gvSS^8^Ns^a^。e(KQehg。Q _[ (2000) @bRgvNCQ~glwmT'YW^NVE^:WvTgvR]4ls^_YevLNTNN(WN0W:SQs^'YQQgTQ0WW,g/f*N~v>yOSg`S6eeQk_NOvNT(W'Y~70,000*N0We'`^-N8f0(Feuerwerier1983, pp28T Skinner 1964, pp3-44)0 _N1。/f-NVQQg'Y~Rb 7 NY*N0We'`W,g~v>y:S>y:SQgNNNeYO:v8fFO>y:SKNS[NN'YW^SVYvR]T8fgvQgP0VdkYVFUT_SbeQ-NV^:W01uelghQV'`~N^:WlwmW^NvQ/fVQR]vNfQv-N_~pNY/fNYV~NmR]T8fv^8O~p00NNSvW^;`NS/f27.3~vN`S5NNSv5-6% (Feuerwerker1993, pp33)0 1ueW^SSN。N*N'YR]Q@bvNf-N(WNpLV'Y'Y9eNfHesOR]vNekSU。@bNW^SvSU。/flV~NmSU。v;NcRRKNN (Y[^/chg。Q1998Yang,2001,ch.14)0000N!kNLu'Yb_YeqQg92*NW^[Y_>eT}ln。NW^NYLuTc0evLNT-NYON(WNW^SU。weg.0cChang0(1969)v}]NXs(W1912-20t^13.4%, 1921-22t^gNwf'ag1923-36:N8.7񚳈-42s^GWXs:N8.4%te*N1912-1949s^GWXs:N5.6Ų(WNbMRlVeg=。{~bN]NXsN8-9Ų(Chang 1969, pp20-74)0 O~v:N,{N!kNLu'YbQ。NYVNT[-NVle]NvzNSRVO-NVle]N(W,{N!k'Ybgg:gOSU。vwl/ffkelg9hncv[EN,{N!kNLu'YbOYV[-NVvvcbDNMO_Y]NNHhV:ON@b%`vYN_N^ (Feuerwerker1983, pp42)0Feuerwerker:N (pp.120-1) YVbD;xN-NVle]NvSU。KN}Tv^lg[De/ec-NVN@bgvsN]N(W;`sN]N-Nvk(WN!k'YbMRNvlgNM-NVNGWYVbD(W1914t^/f $3.751936t^/f $6.97kpS^ ($20) TbN2m($86) NO_Y0 1930t^NYVbDS`SVluN;`00bebNeYVbDkgv/fe,g`SNvNS0vQ~NmSU。/fNbeg-NV~NmSU。g}YvRS_ete*N-NVvbDs/f5NS1937t^17񚳣t^23ŲN/fe,g~Nml_6R^[yNONNCgvOb_}Y?e^NRV%ONlgNHN:gO;NINL:N00e,gN(WNSvbDs_N:RoN-NVyNONvSU。 (Feuerwerker, 1983, pp047)0000FO/fNx^v/fbb)R_Ne,gyND,g'YYlS:N-NVv[PD,gNFO(Wc6ez-NV*alTNTUSMON:YDNS_cNN_b:N[FUNR6R^SV[:gO;NINv]wQ0O_1947t^Vl?e^v[RON (~Nm萧cv-NV~~lQS) c6RNS_e~-v36.1%~:gv59.4%S'YR]N00_Nb:N1949t^_?e^cLV%SvW@x*NV%S_N/f-NV_eg6R^SV[:gO;NINvW@x[b:N~NmSU。v;N6R^xKNN (Feuerwerker,01983, pp47-48)00002.4lVvQQg~NmNv0W`S;`0Wv34ŲlVegD,g;NIN_vǖ]y0W'Y!jFUNSQN~%v^NnfM00NvCOQy]vW0WTeyCOR0W0_lAmW~[v4lQ(uegb_b:SW'`|^:WVdkdk:SWvR]NNSW^SSYD,g;NIN[gNeg/f-NVgSv:SW0NN'`vyCO~~NQsN ({|yO-NvNN?b0WN~~N) 0COQv^NN[^8^+wzgvCOQ'Y7bSk。Q[gNN]b_bD,g;NIN_yCOǖ]FUNSQN~%v00000-NNSlVQ?e1932t^[849Svg}NyCOQY~vY7hS220Sy0WSё^8^nfMyё;NSsё[irV[0WyTRb0WyNyb__00Vl?e^1934t^vgbJT50.7%vCOQN[irNV[yё28.1%NRby21.2%NV[sёy1934-1935t^vW0Wg>f:yN~peMOR+R:N60຃%T24.62%RRy0.24๴Rb0WyvY。O0W;N/f&TcOy}|]wQ。uNTRb0WyvyёeV[[ir0Wy12.9%vQSeV[sё0Wy11๴(W0W;NNcOy}|]wQ。uv`QNs^GW0Wy~:N43.3ŲV[[ir0Wy(WCOQkONvN:S:NnfM (lV~r1946, Vl?e^~@。1946, Feuerwerker,1983, pp72-90)0W0W6R^vY7hS^8^&{TsND~Nmf[TyCOtvg (Stiglitz,1974, Cheung1969)0NtfS_uN-NΘi_uNvRR4ls^_O^eRb0Wy:NggHevS_Θi_。eV[0WyggHesuNRR4ls^Km^9(uNOeǖcOsQ|ggHesS_ΘiN*Y'Y_NN*Y。eRb0WyTV[0WyO(WT~-NTeQsRb0Wy1ue0W;NNCOQRbΘi@bNyё4ls^Oe0W;NNbbΘivV[0Wy00@bgNW0W6R^(Wyr[agNN/fΘiRbTcOoRv$NQzKNvgObw@bNNX[(WNy6R^(W@bgagNNk@bgvQN6R^OW_NNX[(WNy6R^(WNTagNNk@bgvQN6R^}Y0 sNgO@bgCg~gt (Hart,1995)_Nf(WN[agNNy0WkpN0WfgHe(WSNNagNNgW0Wky0WfgHeVdk(WNTagNNQ6R^OeyCO6R^v}T/f[hQv.0(W1uQY~NSQsvY7hS6R^/f(WNTagNN[TyYBg$NQzvgObw0Vdkte*NNASN~~l-NVvab_` gvQ0u SN/fNN[sN~Nmf[ewcSvNN?eZQv:gO;NINSS0NN?eZQ (OYVlZQ) (uySS)R(uNl[~Nmf[vew:NNZQKNy)RgRvQ_g/f4xOWNgHes6R^b_bv:g6R;xN~NmvSU。001ue{|SS~V[Nl_KNNOr"NTlQlN[hQvCgR[:NN_[~Nm~p?elRqNv?el8nbRvvL_NN*Nv`O0000NV:NO1879t^V25.6%vQ7b:NCOQ1945t^*NkONGS0R34.5% (eNASt^N-NVv[hQCO7bks) FOVvQNuNR(W1879-1945t^'Y'Yc0@bNyCO6RksNuNRKNv^lg_6qvvsQ0 (Feuerwerker, 1983, pp85)01930t^vW0Wl-NgNag>k~NCOQePg~~Cgd^0W;N6eVW0W0yag>kv^N)RegHesvW0W6R^vb_b0}6qNag>k(WNVASt^NvVlZQlt:SWv^+g%Ne:S (1946t^_) ^8^nfMVl?e^vP6Ryё?eV{(WbebNevkQQc6R0W:S_NnfM[L0N?eV{_NV4xOWNN[1uQY~6R^vO_[~NmSU。gbq_T0(Feuerwerker,1983,0pp.72-85)099t^N-NVQNuNRN4l;zNNzeflieve,gk99t^Ne,gNO99。USNvS_eS_evVFORRuNs/fVv1/14.fS_ev-NVQN}lsNSFO_NN/f^8^=_0000FO/fte*NlVeN"NCg1uellW0WllQSlvT[LnsNS0n+g?e^SNaOr"NvL:Nb:N^l-NV O~vCOQv8lCOCgi_S0W;NVS0W_8lSNNSNNVW0Wvi_sNW0W1upNVSi_TSlHhO@bNf0lVegv-NVQQgOcWusT{kNsW,g~vQQgNS`SNSv75%QNNQ`S;`NQv65๴wSeQR]4ls^vNS;N/f'Y-NW^NSS`SNSv6Ų(Feuerwerker,1983,pp,33,pp,85)0000~NmSU。vsQ.v^N(WeW0W9ei (vQgHeg__/fbv) (WeNfHesv9e["NCgT1uQY~1uONvObebv9eOOR]Qvib'YTuNRvek0(Sachs and Yang, 2001)0000@bNbN^。fYlaR>e(WlVegFUNNёNTl_6R^vSS0002.5lVFUN0NN0ёN00cgqPerkins(1975,0pp.115-65)TFeuerwerker(1983,pp.28-33)v}lVegvQQg}6qW,g/f~vFONNFUN(WFUNSvW^Tlwm0W:SkN,=_V[Sy:NFUND,g;NINbSYD,g;NINNwm[llwm0W:SN_lAmWvQN0W:SvVQ8fT;N(Wg~m9TuN-NvR]/fNFUNv;Nua (Rankin,Fairbank, Feuerwerker,01986, pp.12-27)0 Perkins (1969,0p.72):NNRKNNvFUT/f(W0We[g^NNfvN:N0FUNeRJRQl0veelgt9hnc_NlgS`ve.s}0000yFUND,g;NINNFO[FUNR]vRmNTvNNFUNYt8fvNTsNN'hvQsNOS6RFUN;mRvLOTFUOvQsNNuNvS_Sv-NV]vёQ0q。hyS1。/f7hN*N^FUNS_@bёgRvQ[SLS%c'^RvhyncSO70Ty^TS__N(WlwmTS0W:Sb_bQ0Ty`N`lTyl ({|kv_g[hQ_sQz;NCgXRNsQzs0099t^N?e^_N6eVNNyLuFO6eVyLuv~NmHeg/fbv01930t^SzN,gMO9e:Nё,gMO1928t^vz~NehQV"?e|~TyBgz~Nb-N.Y?e^vz6eS0We?e^vW0Wz1933t^~N'^QNN。PbkO(u$N1935t^?e^(uYGlPY:N/ec^zwsNS~^6R^$N[hQybk(u。O'^00[ev-NV-N.YL-NVLNLck_SLN~^?e^_YLt^^{z6eT"?ebJT6R^'Y'Y9e0sN?e^:P8R6R^_Ne1931-1932t^SU。weg00:P8R;N1uV[?e^LSNwmyNL-pN0000?e^LTeS%c-N.YLTFUNLvR[FUNRO*alTV[:gO;NINL:N6R^S00'YyNLNV'Y[eLvNNNS[c_NO[FUR~I{OWD,g;NINvyrrQsFO/fN 1949 t^N_v6R^vk,yNLN(WlVegvS_1uTS1928-1937 t^qQg 160 [yNsNL^z[Nbg1,597*NR/e:g-00sNLD,gN 1928 t^v 1.86 NCQX 1935 t^v 4.47 NCQX[>kN 11.2 NX 37.8 NCQ0FO1ueV*N[eLvWe0WMOvS_'YvёDn;N(ueg:N?e^cO~NbNvQ9(uecNfHesvlQqQe^vk*Y。V'Y?e^L1ue[FUNR_NNc^:WzNv_gHe0W/ecg)RSVv~NmSU。00000ze)R(Cheng,1998)fsNёT~^6R^vSU。SN'Y'YcNfHesVOR]vochQ>yOvuNR0FO/f1ue-NVlgwck~N1928-37t^-N.Yc6Rv"?e6eeQ 70% (ue~NbN-N.Y[0We"?evc6R(W1929t^S0RYm_l_l[__lTlWSNw00-N.YT0We?e^v/eQe1931-1936t^S`SVl6eeQv3.2-6Ų'Y'YNOeV?e^1929t^v8.2񚕐yr+R/fN!kNLu'Yb_1ue?e^。'Ye,gyNON6eR_VgO[RON[]NvWe'Y'YR:_:Ne_-NV]NVgST|b6RyN1uONv6R^SU。R N~Nm~gNvagN0000lV_g1ueVl?e^(WbN-N1Y)Rё"?eSO|)]n's200ŲVdk~^b:N?e^bRNl"Nve_Nl~~_~^N(uV0RFUT'^TNirfirvNfe_O~^9eNfHesvRNS%cVR]4ls^'Y'YNMuNR)]n (Feuerwerke, 1993, pp.99-120)0000lVeNNagN_NhsNNCQ~Nmvyr_0'YR'irN/f1u=_v O~e_1933t^ O~Kb](g9}QRe_[Vl6eeQv!.s/fsNe_vNP01915t^e,g(WNSuNv&qdq5.74CQN(T0RIl3/f24.54CQN(TNf9(u/fuNb,gv3.27P0;N/fV:N?elN[[^ b0ng+gt^qQO 9,618 lQlVqQO 15,000 lQvQ-NNRKNN1ue,gN(WNS^00ngW,glglQ^Vl?e^R1ue~NbNvLN'Y!jlQ^qQOb116,000lQ'YR/f 1928 t^_VlZQ?e^@b^00NwmsQU_^:gRv'ire1920t^N_YNM(Feuerwerker, 1983, pp.91-92)0000ze)R(KQehg。QT _[ (Cheng, Sachs, and Yang, 2000, Sachs, Yang, Zhang, 2000)f(WN*N1u~Nm6R^N1ueR]XRuNRv}YYTXRNf9(uvOWYKNv$NQzGWavR]4ls^1uNfHesQ[0NfHesgNOegOv~Nm~g1。/f~vQuNRNON_NlgNf9(u0S_NfHes(Wlwm0W:Sz_cFOSlg0RN。@bgNwSeQR]eRS0W:SvNOwSeQR]NNO0W:SvNNN6q~0Ygg$N*NV[V[KNlgyl1uRNfHesvV[-N@bgNwSeQR]4ls^lgNCQ~NmNfHesNOvV[lwmagN}YvE。lNYV8fNagN]v0We~NuNCQ~Nm0(WyNCQ~Nm-N8fagN[=_VN)R00=_VSN(uObsQz9e8fagNFOtSNb6RR]vSU。:NNN00Yg=_VNek9eNfagNRSNSVsQz$RbY1u8fOVQVER]4ls^cuNRc@bgNvy)R4ls^c00lV_gT 1949t^_T 1980 t^NMR-NV/f(uvMRNy~NmSU。el0S~n1960t^N_-NV1980t^N_(uv/f_Nyel0N0-NNSNlqQTV~NmS (1950-1978)003.1e?elT~Nm8nbRN~NmSU。。8nbR:NR0klNtSvObs%[vSRwNwZi8s (NSlTf[8s)iOgN。8nbRvR01uee-NVbz_v?el8nbRgkT[g'YvS[ZQ:Ne_gb?eZQv:gO;NINL:NcON6R^SvagNVdkON|R~Nm6R^T~Nm?eV{vbrN%N0fv/fVlZQNlb1Y%-NNSlVNvX[(W-NNSNlqQTVSbSN*N-NVb_b$N*N-NV@。b0 1949t^_gb?eZQ。Vl?e^v6R^T?eV{-N>yO;NINV }TMR'Y'YcHQ/f{_^vW9e0YMR@bsN~Nmf[fyCO6R(W1uQY~6R^NYgbN[/f^yr[agNvgHesT~[c0qQNZQ:NyCO6R^/fy0W;NeRJRQlv6R^VdkTW0WbDvNNFO[~Nme!.sS/fjr0(Wyab_`c[Ne1950t^(W-NV_U。vW0W9eiRNFOSNbb-NqQNZQ。OQvNQOr0W;N"Nv[?ebNrNNYRNj_Y0W;Nv"NNFOOTN(WOTz-N@g[N_Y0W;NSvQ[^。0yV[P``;NINL:N1。NFO/fNy[~Nmf[vewN_N/fV[:gO;NINvgzV[?eCgrNSN{|j@gj0{|jLvTlS:Ne_S!k?elR-NV[rNvSN{|jL_N[6RHQO0-NqQ[ev[ ONvXyW9e_0RQl/ecFOhTzlv。0fΘ0S Teiwes ve.s}-NfvS_RQlv^N/ecW9e (Teiwes1962, pp.85-88)0W9e-Nck_YQv0W;N'Y~(W20N80NRNW9eReNONSb{kv0W;N[Q;`qQ'Y~@g[NN~vN~vNN (Stavis, 1963, pp228)0ckYTeiwes (pp.85-88) @b}W9e}[ O:N>euNRvKbkFO[[E(ueg。O:N?elRXTvKbk(u?el[。O:NZNRXTOhzwqQNZQvZCg0(WW9e_vGSSi}TRNSNSI{N|RR-N(uNaOrNCgN~Slz_(uZQ@bc6Rd~vORegcR?e^v?eV{I{I{b:N1950-1979t^-NVgb?eZQltV[v;NKbk0W0W9ei[~NmSU。vbq_T;N/fgvSNVNVgSU。vhswQeg0W0W9eiN9h,gNRGdN-NVN["NCgvO__NccNlQl?elCg)Rv"NCgW@x0[NNbDT~%yN"NTONg9h,g'`vq_T0 Mokyr (1990,1993) Nkl16-17 N~v~NmSU。vhsSW0W"NCg6R^v]+R_QN[W0WygCgObvz^[~NmgSU。gcksQ|v~ _N8^ (Cheung,1969) _NSsS~nvTs^W9e[~NmSU。gbq_Tv~nc0000W9evwgHeg1ueNQb~_gy^b`Yvckbq_T_:SR@bNv^NfKm^0y^vb`YO~Nmb`Y0(W1950-1953t^v~Nmb`Yeg-NV?e^v~NmQV{/fV[:gO;NINTR[s(WQbeel;N;NIN~Nm?eV{vbvmT0V[:gO;NIN;Nhs:N?e^N[s(WQbeg[wckl;NS[NZQN?ev?elbN(W1950t^[^[L]N6~:N[vNll;NN?e0yV[:gO;NIN1uw4Ne[l。O(uv0qQT~01。_Y (?b~-N 1984, pp.1-2)qQT~lQ__NqQNZQ(WQbeTlvI{'YS[ZQ。OQvS[NZQr[swckl;Nvb0b/fT;N(WΑZQ(WQb-N/ec-NqQS[VlZQvagN0qQT~NqQNZQOb"Nvb_S:N0gek0W。。^JS。^W0W@bg6R9eS:NQlvW0W@bg6R0v?eV{ (?b~-N1984,p.2)0qQT~cQ0Ob]NQl。DN6~TleDN6~v~Nm)RvSyg"N-NNSNlqQTV~Nm^v9h,ge/fNlQy|Q~RD$N)RWaNNR0N[:y}(W1950-1953t^w0RObyN]FUNv。O(uFO。NRbgNTCg)RvI{~_Nl_bMRN/fNNs^I{v8nbRvHQO01951t^^_YvNSR (S*alSjm9S[P;NIN) S1952t^^_YvNSR (SwPzozSL?:kSvzV["NqS[Nl)RvSf)RTP[XT)_N(u?elROr"N[yNON[NCgvHQO_YyNON[N~NUOl_z_eN@g045 NyNON-Nv 3/4 cc:NgN[N。ON[?e^v]。O~sQbNSNaZ (Riskin, 1987)0.e?e^vV[:gO;NINL:Nhs(Wga^z?e^[~Nm蕄vWeTvcc6ReS_$RSS_tXT)R(u~NmNvWeyrCgNlN)R0ck/fVlZQgb?eeqQNZQgRybTb]gb?eeN[>e_v:gO;NINL:N0e?e^Ngb?e1。SbQёYGl1upNVS.UcNbCSYGlTё~~FUsQ^0l6e@bgYVLT_YYV'YlQSl6eVl?e^vlQSLe,gNvyNONVdkO?e^vcTcc6Rv]N`S]N;`NQvkN1950t^v45%NGS0R1953t^v63%?e^c6RvFUN(W1950t^_N`S0RybS8fv24%T.UNv15�t^[LY8V[Wev^_Y[]QNirDTY8LV[We0YRgrё^。wx'YFT 43% vWN0?e^We|0h8fv:gg_N_YSU。 (?b~-N, 1984, p33)0?e^[ёTYGl8fvWe_N(uegSbQyFU (?b~-N,p34) 0N]NNt^^vVRby%ONfLagO_Y9eSn+glVv1uONTRlQ6R^ }6q[OObyNONvTlCg)RFOtSBlyNONpTR~Nm:N?e^OryNON"NZPN6R^QY (?b~-N,1984,p37)0000NSNSNSvQNSbQb:gPbTP6RyNFUNv?elR bN[eSrzf[(Riskin, 1987) bvFUN'agOy%lQS%NNM42% (?b~-N, 1984, p69)T。O>y-NM 33% (?b~-N,p73)V%FUNVdk^X[NCSt^vWaNNS1uAmR6R^NQX[(WP6RNNN1uv7bS6R^_Y[L (?b~-N, p142, p151)0 S_eHNI{NcQWe|h8fvt1u/f1ue]NS^NQNT SbQyFU FO[E/fNyV[:gO;NINL:N0 1ue?e^FUNT]NONelNyNONzN :NNNlN)R (uFUNWeegO?e^]NONS[XT@b(WvW^SN(uNlQs^Nf[QQgLeRJR0~-~NFO[g~NmSU。gg'YbHegNeS_e1。 bN^:W%NON^Bl*s,|1ue~-~v[Le1954t^1955t^Qs%NON^Bl (?b~-N, 1984, p116, p121, p139, p152)0tSb:N-NqQBlNekcLFUNTQNT。OSvt1u (?b~-N,p153)0S_e(WΑv^qQNZQNX[N~NmHegg]v?eV{gvS_'YvS[XtS``9e SI{?elRT?el[vZ@bS6R01953t^6g15eklN(W-NqQ-N.Y?el@。ONck_>e_Qbe[vQN(WΑZQ。OQvNdNZQrNd>yO;NIN[swckl;Nvbck_>e_el;N;NIN。>yO;NIN9e QQgT。OS]NVgSqQNZQNZQr。O:NZQ(W!negv;`~01954t^[lSck_nx[NV%~Nm>yO;NIN~NmvyrCg0WMOBlekNhQl@bg6RNfD,g;NIN@bg6RNSU。uNT。O>y。O:N9e *NSOKb]Nv;NS (?b~-N,p125-126)0*N[6R8nbRv9h,glS_eg(W1957t^S0R-NVl;NTvQ*N(WΑZQvS9_0V:NN'Y(WΑZQQbe/ecqQNZQvagN/fqQNZQ[svQ[l;N[?eTS[NZQN?ev[6Rb00003.2>yO;NIN]NVgSTQNT。OS0001954t^?eRbcRyNONVgSvagO*NlQyT%RHQ(u?elRSRZyFU6q_(u~-~T?e^[ёFUNY8vWeP6RNyNONvu6q_Q(u~ON@bgNa_'`CgT{tLMOvRl[slQyT%g_(Weie^bkyNCg[hQ[sVgS0(?b~-N,1984,p123)0-NqQe1954t^_YcRQQgT。OS,{Nek/fOYuQl*NN[uNDeCgvR~T。O>y6q_[s^bkyN@bgCgv~T。O>y;N(u6~eN?el]。Ove_cR (-N.YQQg]。O,{V!kNRT。OOeN?b~-N, pp128-129)0000*NT。OSRv~NmHegg]S0RQlvb6Rc-NqQ0sQeteT]VQNuNT。O>yvw0@b}0Y0WeF~ge^>yWSce%YT>yXT>yvsaSu0TeY0WeQs'YybQVS。u@gxhI{sa0 (?b~-N,p137) 01ueQlvSb-NqQNN~r^;N _/ec?aSR>ebaT。OSekO0FO/f(W1955t^10gv-NqQ-N.YmQ!khQONN0S>P:gO;NIN0yb$RklNcQ:_6R[sT。OSvwQSO^Bl(W1957t^R70-80%`Q7b[sT。OS0[EN:_6RgbLv~g1955t^^QQg1。W,g[sT。OS0Nb (1996pp34-37) ~}N?e^r^(uTyKbkTN?el[:NZ:_QleQ>yvnc0ZQSxvz01981t^,{Ng,{6ucONR~>yv>yXTuNDe@bgCgS0ROrvnc0 VdkgN-NVf[cyT。OSRN?a:NW@xve/f[hQNTS[v0000-NqQcRT。OSvt1u;N/f*NNQ:WN)Re:ghSN)Re)R(uuN-Nv!j~NmN)Re:N]NcOSe|0NlN(WsN~Nmf[-N~b0R/ec0e,gv。W0W@bg6RbR0W[sN:ghS1。fNNvew0(Wg1uW0W^:WvagNNNNe,gON[TQlyeg_Y。WWW0WTv^b'YQ:Wǖ]LFUNSNNS'Y!j~๵ueuNRcW0Wv@bgSsy0Wvyё6eeQe]y0Wv6eeQ0SN1upNVSyAvW0W_NOe(uT~ve_L'Y!jQ0u4l)R^0FO/f(Wlg[hQW0WygCgT1uvW0W^:WagNNL'Y!j:ghS~%TQ0u4l)R^1。O4xOWoRV。!j~%vW0WbS6R}6qONN[oRtSN)Re:ghS[hQvW0Wyg6R1uW0W^:W1uQY~MbQ{|$N0lgNUO~Nmf[vtSfQNT。OSOcuNRFOfT。O6RONHesNOeyNONv~Nm!jWtSWl[rEQh0[EN1954]^bv67N*NT。O>y1/4S_t^QN (Nb1996pp34-360ZQSxvz01981t^,{1gp6) 01955t^T。O>y[r{kN60% (RR}0QQg*geg01988 t^,{ 2 gez) 01955t^-NqQ-N.YfNY>m0RYm_lvg~cQ0(W15*NSfSu60YwOqN_SSN*NS{k10*NNOch9hT_80 (0ZQSxvzDe0 ,{9 p.698)0RNT。OSeQl'Y`。@g[r*sv`Q (0-NVQNT。OSDe01992t^,{3gp1) @bNT。OShQV~v|hNXR/fNNQ~gmbfR'Y*s,%Nw::NNNv0Vdk-NVvQNT。OS[uNRv^lgckbq_T0QNT。OS[-NVQNuNRgSU。vbq_T/f_f>fv ((KQehg2000) 00003.3T_'Yc]NS00:NNt-NV1959t^N_Y[Lv>yO;NIN~NmbN{VT{NN$N*NvQN/f:NNHNT_>yO;NINSO6Rg~f~~[v'YYpeV[@bb_vQN/f:NNHN7hNySO6R(WvQg~b_NMRYuX[0 OduS_wgNNwvv~NmX~He,{N*NNNRvsQT_~NmSO6Rvyr_/fNHNN。bNHQVT{N*NbNHQRgT_>yO;NINSO6RTklNv>yO;NINSO6RKNv:S+R0000pQyO;NINYQ~Nm;uvNSSv{b,g0(W^:W>yO;NINNAQgm9T^:WFO@bgONTuN }/fV[@bg0-N.Y;u:gsQ}TNhQVgONv{tg'YS~[NyO;NINYkD,g;NINSO6RfgHe0WMnDn0T6KQ (Hayek,1988) T__f (Friedman,1962) NTa0NN:N-N.Y;ulgoRNyO;NIN~Nm"NYnCgR^。eY0irN@。0RR@。0?e^T]N萌TONv{t0Y[gbDSvsQvDnMngQ[CgirN@。[irNgQ[CgRR@。[NN[cgQ[Cg?e^T]N[-NgbDTSPgeSbeQ }vMngQ[Cg]S~t[e8^{tQV{gQ[Cg0@bgCgvSNR_6eeQbbb_c1YvCg)R(W"?e萌TT]NKNRRVdklgUS*NNb:gg[NNVg"Ng[hQv@bgCg0-NVNyKN:N0lgwckgvSO6R0b0@bgCgZnvSO6R00gN(WlgNCg~gNUO[('`9eSv`QN7hNySO6RvNUORCgT1uSv9eiO bk[@bQvfYv0 _~ (1999) cQNQ*NgTvNS[tVg6RagNNwckvON[NSQs?eOR_NS{~_glxSNS4xNNSgHe0W~_g~tNVg:N;N[vlQSS9eiNSQ~%b0Nez-NgN{ (_[^V1988) cQ*NN[YglgS_vyNNCg@bgCgvNT~bR(WRrRv:ggKNvyRM/fN*N_vjv`07hNy6R^[c!jNsNlQSvc6R|~[/fNy6Ra:g6R0y6Ra|~Ng[XTv'YyrCgv~TcONN*NgHevc6R|~NS{t*N|~voR0 _N8^ (Cheung, 1974) 0S[OT旯eyO~g[cgqNv~+RegRMyyOv)Rv:NNN_rSNNv)Rv0ytasTWw:/f:NN~I{~6Rv>yOy^cOckS_t1uEea bv (_N(W[XTNv。oa)0 S[OT旯eyO;NINNvnfMw:t fw:/f?e^[XTbSWeyёvNyel [(uegcvWe)Rm VQ。lQO[WeyёvNn /fkvcvWeNyO;NINteHe09hnc _N8^0S[OT旯eyO~gNYg?e^vvh/f)R(uw::N[vWeCgcOckS_t1uvbN`cg[9hncBlegNyO;NINN。Ov~0SYr)Rv^:W>yO;NINN*N~ (Kornai,1986)06q*N~lgVT{bNv,{N*N(W1930t^NT1950t^NTv^l~^:W>yO;NINFO[v-N.Y;uSO6RNNx^X[Neg(WNb_ Od0RNYV[[S_N193340t^t^GW8%T194858t^t^GW9.4% vXsN9eieN-NVvXsT7hNNwv (Sachs, Woo, and Yang)0:NNHNQs|^XeTT6KQN_R~NmvwgbR=。{NNcknx0WN_SO6Rgv1YŲQs|^Xe0T6KQ0__f0 _N8^SS[Ov>yO;NINRglgblaR>e(W*NN0(KQe (Sachs, 1996) (KQe,,Thg (Sachs,Woo,Yang,2001) ~*NcONN*NT{Hh0bNs(Wi*NT{Hh0Y(KQeThg (Sachs and Yang,2001) ve[!jW@b:y~NmSU。/fRRR]ovN*Nz0yr+R0WThg (Ng and Yang,1997,Sachs and Yang,,{15z) cQ(WN*NgPt'`vNLuRRR]vo1u>yOTyRRR]!j_@b_v~~DNS*NNsQe!j_vR`QV{KNvNN。O(u@bQ[01ueX[(W>yO&^egvD6evNb,gKNv$NQzRRR]v}YYTNf9(uvXRKNv$NQz@bNS_TNfvHesevRRR]v!j_1。Y^:W_v~~D_NY0e6q>yOSek_gsQRRR]vgHe!j_vDS_NN:ON~~De(WYBgvRRR]!j_KNMRHQN{USvRRR]!j_hf~NmSU。/f*NNRRR]v{US!j_0RevYBgv!j_vekoz06qYThg (Ng and Yang, 1997_N Sachs and Yang,2000, ,{15z) @b:yYgSV[ekv>yO]~SsNRRR]vgHe!j_~NmSU。v_egYRRR]v-N6kvc!jNRRR]vgHe!j_0(WSV[D,g;NIN6R^gRe1u^:WgvQ0N[vRRR]!j_0SD,g;NINV[R vMQ9~~D:N_egv'Yc]NSR N:gO'Yc]NSgS1uv^lgD,g;NIN6R^W@xevT_>yO;NINSO6Reg[sD,g;NIN6R^W@xe/fSsgHev]NS!j_v9h,g0(W:OND,g;NINW@x6R^e!jN1uD,g;NIN6R^R v]N!j_eg'Yc]NSyS'`/f1930t^NT1950t^NT_>yO;NINV[v[bR0W]NSvtW@x1ue_euNyS'`T6KQTQs|^XeN0R20N~-NgT_~NmSO6Rvx^X[0 OdTNNwvvX~He0000:NVT{,{N*NbN{0WRR-NV(W1959t^N^zwegv_>yO;NINSO6Rvyr_YN00(1) OcQNT[]NTvv[NONv^c6R@bgONySO6R)R(uhQONvV[@bgCgT-N.Y;ueg_Vg]N蕄v)Rm0VgONv)Rm(ueg!jNPs0bDsT]LNk{]LNfvXs0y]NSU。!j_1uD,g;NIN]NSz@bR 0OncSThg (Shi and Yang,1995_NSachs and Yang, 2002,{12z) ve[!jW]NvXsXRuNvVuNagTuNDeLNv6eeQkeg[s/fRRR]ovN*Neb0000(2) ONvV[@bgCgT-N.Y;uSO6R(ueg~~~T'`v]NbDRNR(W[Yy]NTv^:WNX[(WeTeRzNY^8^NNSv]NONy~T'`vV[bDR_SNRRR]Q!jv'YO^NNSv]NLNy{|Su0y~T'`vV[bD;u(W1930t^NvT/fǖ(uYegSD,g;NINV[vN[6Rv (Zaleski,1980) (W1950t^Nv-NV/f(WegTTN'kvN[vcRN[bv0y~T'`vV[bDRASRgHe0W)R(uNsQeRRR]vgHe!j_TRRR]vNNQHegvMQ9~~D0vQyrO1。/f1950t^N-NVv694*N'YW]zyvTTc^v156*NsQ.]zyvvR*NR(W_weQ(WY^NNSvONbR0WR^NN*N^'YvRRR]QS_elgN^NNSvuNDev^:W (?b1984) 0OY。O:N156*NsQ.]zyvKNN(WN_vcRNN*NNNuN(ue:g^]NvN ёRwvON(W]^bS_e[:g^vBlNN/edN*NuNN ёRwv'YWNNON07hv?e^bDRN'Yc]NStvS_N0(WT;uS_@。[D,g;NIN]N!j_T'Yc]NS!jNve.s}NNbReW (Zaleski,1980) ~b0R0R[ (Lenin,1939) RRQN[D,g;NIN]NSyr_vt_egT;uS_@。!jNN[0-NVv'Yc]NSv}N?b (1984) ~b0R0000(3) -N.Y;uS_@。vS_|~0W!jN]NhQS'YybuNuN~D,g;NINlQS~tN0S^TOKNv6Ra:g6RlRyf[{t((W-NVy:N[{t)0NSD,g;NINONSU。QegvvQN~~!j_T{tel0TN"NvYnT6evCg(WT]N0"?e0V[L0Y0irN@。0irD@。TvQN:ggKNvRrR?e^^zwN:ggKNv6Ra:g6R0-N.Y;uS_@。y6Ra:g6R[te*N~Nm^zwN*NvS_gHevc6R:g6R0gB。?e^TZQv[XTqQT[;uSO6RlviRYOg"}SCg0VdkNNgoR。O*NSO6Regg'YSiRYO0R[:NT-N.Y;u^S_bte*N~Nm~~bN*N'YlQS0FO(Wy6R^vvB。lggHev6Ra0?e^TZQ~~(WbzlQST(W@bgLNgWeCgN1688t^(WVRzvwQg1u~>y (SbyNONvR{v6R) TrzSl|~v[?ey^b_bf[gqy[?eSO6R(W?elSvvB。^zN6Ra01ue:ONyvB。vCgR6RaT_>yO;NINSO6R:N6R^SvV[:gO;NINR N_'Yzz0000(4) -N.Y;uS_@。(W:ON-N }^:Wv`QNO(uNWYirDs^ahTN*Nvz_egOFUTvOs^a0*NSO6RvS_}YvcяRf`+Y (Leontief) vbeQNQl@b_Qv~g0[e-NV50t^NirDs^azv。ONLuL(WorldBank,1984) cON~vU_06qRf`+YbeQNQlNQNTbeQKNvfN[Nnx[[m9Tvg~Bl_NNcOOSN>f:yvQyNDvgHeoR:g6R0WpQ (Roland, 2000, ,{Nz) ~NNN~Nm!jWN!jWf-N.Y;uvR`z_0RvGWa/feHesv0000(5) 6q!jND,g;NINbRv]NS!j_TD,g;NINONQ!j_/f4xOWNu]NST~~vbR!j_vD,g;NIN6R^W@xeeg[sv0/f,{N!k-N.YCgSv~Nm6R^v>yO0-N.YCgv>yOvHQQagN/f(W6R^[cv^zWeCg/ffRi}T0fROryNNCgT:NpeOYvnmR-Nv~rP``eg[sv0(W6R^[cv:ONlQs^zNasTWbv6R^[cNSgHe0T_>yO;NIN~NmSO6R/f1uN*N?e^gav,{NySO6RN/fNSvoTSNlQs^zNNNCgv?aNfvNN。O(u-NQsv0T6KQ(Hayek,1944,1960,1988):NgHev6R^[cS。O:N7hlQs^zNT?aNfv~gQs0(KQe (Sachs,1996) :N!jNSD,g;NIN~Nmv]NS!j_vV{eu(W:OND,g;NINW,g6R^eYNuwgNNwvvX~He06qS_!jNv。oR]~=。bRRR]vQS_evYBgvePyV{euvgNN。[vwgHevV:NySO6Rlgb6R^ReRSvsQv6R^W@xe0fN,vS_~NmSU。v_egVvNlgN*N/eMNRv?elRRv0W?elsXNTV[~Nm~Hev]_。Nu9eSab_`T[?eRvSR0`vOab_`TS_QRvSSk~Nm~gvSSba_Y0^S_la0RklNv>yO;NINSO6R,g(NR NNy6R^B。!kNv6Ra0VdkklN[-NzNOeav?elv[NN(WvQ1956t^0AS'YsQ|0v-NcQL?eRCg(k1977a) 0N?elzN/f-NVTOWe6R^oS]+Rv'Yof0000NASt^NW^-NSuN$N*Nv~Nm6R^SSN*N[~NmSU。gbq_TSN*Ngckbq_T0?eRbe1954t^5g6e^bkNn+glRSU。wegvN)R6R^(uSSf[[:NlgzNRvb4xNTT_v uNvSfb/g9eSTtS^vVYRfLagO (?b~-N,p117)01955t^6g?e^LXTvI{~h%Nv[irM~6R9e:NNAS]N~]D6R(?b~-N,p145)dkSS[~NmSU。gO。O(u0000NASt^NcLve6R^NV[:gO;NIN6R^SV[[~NmvhQbWeTc6RSOr"N:Nyr_0ye6R^(W18N~v'k2mef/fglgzNRv6R^@bNASkQN~cL{|y'YTNt^'YeRN{kNgYvN*NN:N`gRNFON{|SS}veRN*ggYdk`pN{|g}vbN-Nv{kNNpe_N*g!k'YeR-Nv{kNNpeN/f(W_}Yt^bSuv1ugb?eN:N bv`gR0gf[cQEead4xOWNS bYdk``v~@。0-NVQYvf[N)YTa!kSeNt^v'YeR{k。NCSNN0-NV[eShvCgZvZQSNW:N01959t^1961t^v^ck8^{kNTQ。QuNSpe(WVCSNN]S0 (N0fbSU。v。g0,{NwSp.272) -NVf[ё (1993) NV[~@。ShvpeW[:NOnc{v~g/f0NN-NVQQgv^ck8^{kNNpe1。SVCSVASN00wmYf[Nb(1996, p.7)N[eDe:NW@xv8h{_N_Q。NCSN~vNN{kv~0wmYf['YYTaNt^eR{kNpe:NNCSNv0O。uvNpe'Y~(WNCSN~vN (Chang and Wen, 1998, Peng, 1987, pp.639-70, Kane, 1988)0000Nt^'YeR/fCgN6R6R^S bvNxy%Nz^vN*Ng}YHhO01ueGSSSSSS>PRI{N|R[S[>mv?el[R-NVqQNZQv?eCgb:NN*N[hQNS6R~vePCgR0[SS>mRv=。}Nb (1993) [SS>PRv}Nb (1996pp.37-86) [NSNSGSSve.s}Teiwes, (1962,pp85-88)0NR_?e^[N,TN0R>yON{kNgYv'YeR0c _#kTe/-N (Chang and Wen, 1998) NSNbve.s}eRHQ1u'YpY0 1958t^klNSR'YR(WuNRSg599N(TvagNN BluN1199N(T0 1ueS9h,gNS0R*NN N_YSShQlp Vdk(W'Y}Yt^bbQlXRR_SZPWp。QlvpwQpb^(W*Nz-N'Yg(gkc0RNklNN6R[Q。Oel (QNkQW[[l) :_Qld^[iO_Y^yR。QNT。O>yTv^b?e>yTNvNllQ>yNO?e^[hQc6RQQg~Nm0qQNZQr^(WNvRN_YQYcMReQqQN;NIN(WNllQ>yRlQqQXTmNmmp[^[sQNS7uNsYNR_SOE。OObkQlv?bK。NO-NE。OO0VnWS[aNSbkNRKNNvl?b (Nbp47)0@bg>yXTvyg"NhQEQlQVN。Qlv(WlQ>ySMR@g*sxh01ueT~r^(WklNvSRNZbnm8YNklNN:N|TN[cQXRlQ| ([irQNz) 0[sNvhvKbk1。/fSS>PR0 nc。s^1962t^5g(W-N.Y]。OObJT SS>PR[ENq_T0RNCSNNvQ-NN~vQASN/fpyb$R[:NS>P:gO;NINRP[vr^ZQXTgfYR:NoQS>m0W[SOWRP[ (Nbp.220-221) 0(Wy?elSRNT~r^:_N~bNNbNceO (Nbp.222)0OYlS _SS1958t^|Nя4P0WZ8YTib'YOV[_-NRbPXR[ENN_-peQNNvS_@bNYu~QlvSgWF(0-NqQZQSDe0, ,{99, pp74-76)0Y5][N70Ne|wYNbvtS/f150Ne[_Q3S1959t^|N/f1.54NeSY[^/f4.05Ne0^NQgSY。[EN1.44Ne8Y'Y:N2.57Ne (Nbp.222)09hncNZbvNklN:N|Y_TN[SNNQ。 1959t^%fdby9CSNN (Nbp.222)0Te(W9gNwmO-NqQQ[XRN~vNe_- (Nbp.223)01uelQqQXTmNhQt^vS|(WNN*NgQT[RNQ6e_-XR1959t^%fYeR1。_Y^_eg(Chang and Wen, 1998)00000(WeR]hbSv`QNT~?e^(WNbvSRtS:N/f6~LeNccqNNbwNyR(WklNBlQl|JSt^|vc:yN_1959t^yTwtQwSwNyRRFcSbWB^'Y!jTQld.R|0uSuyZQYfNST0wBlf0~klNQO0ncbwSvN*NlQ>yV*N^P[vNS{kN`Q/fg:N`NvN*N{kN`S5%N*N11%:_N*N15%N*N`S20%YgvQgP[QNNeNNOO(WbN4NMosQNb6ewegv'YN"N_v?Qz~NV~vN{kNN~vT]S00 (ON0qQTV'YNN~[0,{9wSpp.64-65)0R。GYTN。[NwSNTNNN_NbJTNklN0Nb~SSRtQO4l)RnoBl1958t^v!j0^Q{y4l)R]zz-NQl[hQ'N1YN1uPtYN7hRRr^Sb{kNvNN^8^nfM0WB^'YPS_N/fSu(W*NegWB^)R(uePvCgRxYalYsY:kS~vY*jLaN'YdyrCg (Nb p195, p242, pp151-152)0OSbNvsaNv^~0R1961t^_NN0?el'Y0Sm_^j[6R^gsQ (Nbpp152-154)0ySl6R^vP_egklN;`~:N06~eNNb1。up00QQgWB^'Y-NrNvjLb:NegVnRntvp09hncNSve.sU_ (2000pp.56-62),01959t^{kNv`Q1。Glb0RSN1960t^3gklN[:|。Oc:y1959t^12g-1960t^2gu-nGT?eNSQs'Y{kNvsa-NqQ-N.YybluwYQ-nvayWB。~~mNybSOWRP[r^ON~-N.YbN[Yl:SYt-N/u'Y{kNva:NSV/fl;Ni}TN{_^^ZQ9hP[NckZQ~~%NN~01959t^T0W{kNv`Qb0R-N.Y[1960t^%f-N.Y|蕌T_lwYR+R>m]。O~S_l[^SgnxN:|_w'YybN{kNvN[1960t^2gOw~[r^Sv`Q{-NSb`YNgsQQQgNS0vvYAm00nm^0vQb09hncNNZQQ~[ch1960-1961[_Q3S33NNS{k 6N (я1/3)Su 63 wg}vNTNNN0Nch_eg1u0Q3QQg>yO~NmSU。bJT0NeSh1u/n0_>e0Bg_e1994t^3gS (pp.45-51)RQ01960t^4g_klN[[eZSOvrp[ OeugN[6gN_Y[0Rb/fwck?aab[QQgv%NNvgRS^/f。v#Nc~WB^萄v[P;NIN:_}TNTlqN~ (NSp58)00NGS0R 35600N0R10gNJWN0WYAmmNpe 10 N VS?QVSsY 985 Ng+Y9eZ 869 N*N+RWB。~~][hQ+vu (NSp.60)0000R。GYhTi`egI{NNaNgv~NklNNN7hNNgR;N _Rte?eV{01961t^5g7eklNyblhTi`egyblQqQXv5ubJTU_N,gNNh`FO(WR。GY:_pBlceX_k(W67gv-N.Y]。OONXy0/f&TSRX[hQ1u>yXTQ[00dk_XQNNNYKNhQce (NSp.62, ?b~-N, p.992)0QlYu0Wnb`Y^8f_N_>e0_Yw:SQQgXVe|(W-N.YeNNKNMRsSLSOuSdwN'YS~N01961t^10g5]*NNt^MR'YRXv~ew1。gNRKNNvS[LNSN0R7b0klNgHQUcIc0R~NmYvaNS/cKYweg1961t^9gk(W^q。-N.Y]。OON[^V]0R7^b_RN)Y)YTNGS (NSp.60)0000s(W]gYncklN_e1。['Y!jeR{kNNvv`r[hQw`FONb`S,gRS(ub6~eN?el[OrNCgvRlS6RS['Yvav^CSe~v[~bev?elz4xSeN_?el;NR_N/f_eg>yYeRTei-NNNR。GYI{NSuQzv9h,gSV0000!kNLug'YveRv^NIQ/fklN*NNvjLN/fN6Rrv>yO;NIN6R^。V[:gO;NIN6R^Sv_6q_g0Vdk。~Nmf[VY_;N h(Sen,1977,1981) cQNLuNgv'YeRv^N/fUS~:|_w /fyrCg6~(W|w:e。gPv|-N(ueNNvu;m N~g:|vNB。Nlv%`0 gThg (Lin and Yang,1998) (u-NV'YeR-NvncfNNGP`0'YeRhbSN_T0Wr^萁ybkQlYQR(u%NSbRSbQS_eQQg-NnfMvwPv^m_ZQQ0R'Yv~r^tSQlg6R^:g6Reg6RaklNvCgR000001961-1962t^(WR。GY。s^I{_f>m[N-NVv~Nm?eV{hQbb`Y0R'YMRvrQ0。s^mwVQv%N'`NhQR/ecR。GY1961t^ybr^N[te]VEQ[cve/{_NR;N _Y0}6qh`/eckd6~eNv?elRTeScQ^(WQL0R。GYhTi`eg。s^HN:N-N.Y?eV{v[~vYepezrrra0R_mv'au1962t^YR。GYr_TkBl>e[?eV{Ru[kv0Nv`Ob/fNSfNv00 (0RnUO[hmR。GYNVnR0N{kNvN/fQ0RSfNNSv0vQeR`Ny$a$a0W0bS_;N-^eQNyN0(R1998,pp.103,105) 0R。GYS_e*g0RQyN/fGSSSSSS>PRmmp@bgS[>mv_6q~g01959-61t^v'YeR[NN~r^萄v:Rogm0N`weg1。b_`YNgS0V:N0~p:SNlvQ`NQvzrrrzkbNt^NY0NNnZi0[hQ/fevzrrrJU0 (NSp64)0yNlSbv:gOlgv``XQtSHNy:N0-NVNl[(W}Y{kN_NN`weg S0(NSp64) 01ue~r^NlOHNSNwS>yO[`FO_NS/fgawN[0S[/f1960-1963t^-NVSuNYY[rkv0WN?eZQ;mRvQ-N;Ng-NVl;NZQ-NVRRZQSqQQeVQN/S0NNS[qQNZQv;N?elBl1。/fvzNt^'YeR-NqQNZQvSN{|j0N0WN?eZQ;mR_eg(W1969t^vnt6~O1970t^vNSbNSR-Nmmp (hgfIQ1994t^)00001961t^klN_YnxRwS]N'YxyNS_elfnxS[SN0R7b/fI{0R_egMbS;eP{0N1961t^NQwQSOR。GYI{Nv~OP;mRk_N/f(W*Neg。PbkTFONQ_mYkN:N]gUO0NS_e:NhQZQ[NP[NqNQqN{kNNN_N;eQNb~eY (NSp64)0(WySRN;N _b['YeRs[vkvyfN0u[@g0klN0W:N'Yv1Y%/f1ueQNT|NYcQN0N:N~09e:N0QN:NW@xN|:N~0SV0RN-NVSN1Y%vQbFUKNNN?eV{0NQV{(WkvTN;N _YFOSNlQ_S[kv?eV{agNN b]N'Y!j6e)_YNSv0RQQgOW^S4ls^NMu(WVlNQ~NMNt^_~Nm_Yb`Ye]NN00klN'Y~e1961t^_YQYSQ0N1961t^3g13e~R。GYhTi`eg。s^HNm_wQOybRI{[lQ>yQsQ|0N/fNuNN0kw0RRvq_TRck(WNeib'Y0NVN;N0]b[@。e/fNR'}yblT{|lQeBlTw^,{NfNSU_~NQON_egg6q6e0R _s^SI{Nyb0We[XTblA。;N _'Yb6~eNvON0kTesQ_gj_eP^vbgSR:_6~eNFOhbNS(W1962t^NCSN'YONlQ_b1959t^NegrN (NS,p65) 0FOlNS(WS_t^vkQJ。AS-NOON9T6~eNv~OVc;N[Cg01963t^~Nmb_R[hQ}Yl]QN;`NQ_YNGS_-NqQ-N.Y_YSchP6R)。TNf^8fv^&T[1961t^LKNgHevSNP7b1u^:WI{?eV{(?b~-N,p359)00003.5eSi}TSvQMR_v~NmSU。NN|Rv (OYYemQASag]NNASagQNmQASag) &T[0kvL?eRCgv``_NS0RNvTNvb6RNN;N _d'YWXbbe-N.YT-N~NmQV{CgirN;`@。TWeuNDeAmvirD;`@。_NN1963t^^z (?b~-N, p364)0 y:NagagN?e klNvL?eRCgy:NWWWWN?e0 QN?eV{ebNllQ>yvSO6R[(&T[lQqQXce~NmQV{CgT"N@bgCgNlQ>yN>e0RuNFO/f?e>yTNvSO6R/fOYuNegN (?b~-N,pp306,314,316,348)0 klNsQe(W]NN|~^z?el]。O:gsQzQ?elQ~]D~+RteS[irD:RoNekSbQyFU[W^yN?bN[LVgSvNNp/f(W1965-1966 t^[LN (?b~-N, pp.373-414)0000(W19581961t^v'YT19661970t^veS'Yi}TgNSeS'Yi}TN_N*NgHev-N.Y;uSO6R(W-NV]NYX[(W0Nt^RTt^^;u[ENN/fN~zze01950t^N-NV,{N*NNt^RvbR[klN0W_Q0bRR_eqQNZQ^zv>yO;NINSO6RvO'`0v~0NNf}vbR/fWeT[D,g;NIN~Nmv!jN0VdkkVR N]vqQN;NIN6R^YNllQ>yT'YX0TekgNy:_pvS`aN!P[L?eRCgS[-N.Y;u!P[k*NON0k*NS0k*Nwv~S[NNSTRRR]!P[O~S[N[~!P[b/g=_v。!j~v>yONS[b/gHQv'Y!jVgONI{I{ (k1977b) 07hNeb-NVRRR]oQba-NVQQgN。PYu(W O~v~>yOSNeb[ bN(Wkv-NVOS:g6RvN*Nwzzelg-N.Y;u_Nlg^:WYOS(W,{N*NNt^RSU。wegvRRR]0*Nwzz(WeigQyNONTSOONkXEQ(W1970t^N1984t^_y。OaNGON (TVE) v>yONTRCgvSSYNN6R^@bkXEQ0[eRCgOSv['O(WkveNSU。weg(W['ONvRRR(W^QVgON (Sachs and Woo, 1999 h6)0N1985t^w,(WTSO6RNSMRTRRRv99% (Sb(WVgTSOQ:Wv14%RRR) ~N0mx0 (Cook,1993[T]NOv=。vchU_)0(WN'k~Nmg'YR]N_NNSvyO0=。{!jNTv]NS!j_,{N*NNt^R(W-NVW^SU。N_vRRR]4ls^1978t^MR-NVQQgFUNSz^/f0.30asTW-NVQQgYFUNSb-N.Y;uegSU。RRR]4ls^NN*NNORRR]4ls^SU。NyFUTSv^:WSO6R[fN0FO/f(WN*N-N.Y;uSU。wRRR]4ls^v~NmSU。yNNCgTvsQ^:WgvQV01ueNORRR]4ls^-NVQQg9ei[fNvS1ue-N.Y;u^zwegv_YvRRR]4ls^(W-NVvW^9eifRV06q。O:NN*NteSO-NV9eikOWe[f_YV:N(Weig-N.Y;uSO6R+vuN0Tekv]NSO6RkT_>yO;NINSO6RfRceSTf>PT@。~0000eSi}TNeb/fklN[1962t^n{'Yv@bg~r^萄v'Y!j?elbYT[SNebklNv^lgS/fO(uSg)R(u[P:ggd?el[vel0N1966t^10g_)R(u1949t^Neg[vNl[qQNZQ[PvNnAQgP^v1u?el~>yv^/ecSv S>mSb?el[0(W>yOI{~6RNS0Rgkv4Ne]TT]_N~~ SvQN]N_NcQS[Q~]DVYёS[~NmRM-NzQ?elvTy~NmBl0klNy:N~Nm;NINYΘ(?b~-N, pp418, 423, 425 S 1966 t^ 4 gQ~VYёv-NqQch?b~-N, p410)0eV%]N。P]。PNRNklN/ec4xOW-N.Y;u:gsQv S-NV>yO;NIN~NmSuN{|m~~NNN[zv(WΑNXb_b S>m~~0FO/fklNS[>NQv?el8nbRybkhQV'`?el~~;N _Rw(u?elOSFURlQ S>mNO[>mS S>mQvQz01ue?elOSFU/f1u[e。peNd~vNfNlQckzSlg>NQv8nbR@bN S>m-Nv(WΑVN[T>mKNSuQbte*NV[weQQqN0g_kSN[hQV[LQN{6R~_gRqN00001ueklNvS>PT1966t^-NqQ-N.Y。OQXRND,g;NIN8fsQ|vQ[1972t^-NqQ-N.YybQ43NCQvbWYYTUS:gS (?b~-N,p409)0(Wy^b`Y_SU。:NevND,g;NINV[SbWYYcLSfN'Yc]NSvbeu (?b~, pp.523, 527, 530, 531)0NbeuNv^~0R9ei_>eeN0vQ-N[bWYYSёq。bWYS]YSNSTy5ulm9TuN~vSb:N-NV]NSvW@x0ybeu/fNlQg6RR~Nmv6R^eg!jNyg6RT1u^:WR ve]NS!j_bWYYbDTeb/geYFOtSN!jND,g;NINvl_6R^"NCg~g^:W6R^Tv^voR:g6R00N-N.YT0We[JSR0v^NQw[S^"?eB。B。S~N(?b~, pp475-476)0 0We_N_0Rup;mYt N{|。W]N ONvzsvCgR0kvL?eRCg(W-N.Y0w0ST~?e^TlQ>yKNRRVgONv@bgCg0vS(WThQVgONg~Nv@bgCg00V0-NVv~Nm9ei (1978-2002)0004.1~Nm9eivyrp00klN{k_~N*Nwfv!ng。s^eccCgR0vQ~Nm?eV{;N/fQQgb`Y1962t^vSN0R7b^bklQ>y6R^W^LVgONv>eCg)RScR:SWRCg6R^0SN0R7blNOQQg~Nmb`Y0R1950t^Nv4ls^0FOW0W6R^Nvlgb`Y0R1950t^NRSlVeNv6R^0hg。Qs^VZ。X(1992)~}N-NVQQg1980t^Nv6R^SS0NN(u12*Ncpec[Vy"N (NTRRW0WёDN) Lu[N{|Cg)R (O(uCglCg6evCg) vNfHes0-NV1980t^Nv6R^SSR:NN*N6k0,{N6k:NLu[NTvO(uCg6evCgTLu[RRTW0WvO(uCgvNfHes'Y'Yc,{N6k:NLu[NTTRRvlCgNSLu[RRv6evCgvNfHes'Y'YcLu[W0WlCgvNfHes_Ngc0,{N6kLu[ё"NCgvNfHes'Y'YcLu[W0WlCgvNfHesfc0FO;`SOW0WNCg6R^SSv[eNTRRvNfHesvc。q_T"NlCgv6R^SSS。eq_T"NO(uT6evCgv6R^SS01ueLu[NCgv~TNfHescpeN1979t^v0.384XR0R1987t^v0.642-NVQQgvFUNSz^_NeTgN0.455XR0R0.64509hnchg。QTZ。X (Yang, 2001, ch.16) vNCg~Nmf[!jWFUNSz^S fNR]z^0-NVQQgR]4ls^vcOuNRc0te*N80t^N-NVQQgNGWw[6eeQt^GWXs9% (Yang, Wang, and Wills, 1992)0000v:SWRCg6R^S-N.YTw~?e^v"?esQ|]VNkvL?eRCg0egz6eTVgON)Rmv?e^6eeQOncN[vRMR(W-N.YTw~?e^KNRR0(Wv:SWRCgvegV[pevw?e^6eeQNN~-N.Y?e^(W_gV[kOvw?e^6eeQNN~-N.Y?e^0NklNeNNTv/f-N.Y[T~?e^[LB。B。"?eS~N0Ny-NV_"?eT;NINN*Noz-NQs[:N1990t^N-NV9eicONcRR0(WNLuLv.^RNy"?eT;NINb0We?e^vz6ey{|T_6e:ggN-N.Y?e^vz6ey{|T_6e:ggRy_ (Qian and Roland, 1998, Qian and Weingast, 1997 v"?eT;NINTOV-N.YCgWvT?e^N0We?e^v"?esQ|b_bfv[k (Zhuravskaya, 1998 T Qian, 1999)0 R0WN-NVTOWe9ei~Hev]+R0FO/fbNN^0Ov:SWRCgT"?eT;NIN[~NmSU。v!.s0HQ[rRN^:Wv^XN0WeVgONvWeRR (hT, 1999, UO, 1997, P206)0bcSv:SWRCg~bNkvL?eRCgOWvebV;xNhQV~N^:Wvb_bb (Lardy, 1998a P204) N}lfLN:NOfNNpvQ!k-NVv"?eT;NINNVv"?eT;NINKNg]+Rg'Y0N1954t^_YuHev7bM|6R^g'Y0WP6RNRRRTNRD,gv1uAmR0=。{яegN6R^gN9ei(W'YW^AQlg8lENE。OOCgvylkt^fbcfOO0FO/f(W-NVv'YW^-NNQQgegvylkNNVv~aSylv0WMO0(W-NVyl_{kS_0W8lENE。l/eN_YvP[sYeQf[9TpN?bNyO_N:Ne!jNV{eucONzz0/n0S~nTvQNetQ]NSD,g;NIN~NmcONRR[WQS]NSe!j_vMQ9Dy!j_)R(uS~NmTNS~NmNGWw[6eeQv>fW]_QSRR[W6RbTbcSD,g[WY0egS~nT/nvNSFU&^egNRD,g0ON[b06R^wTD,gN[e-NV!jNevD,g;NIN]NS!j_gvQ0-NV?e^_Nga0Wf[`NS~nT/nv~OY~Nmyr:Seu/f[S~nTvQND,g;NINV[QSR]:ST1u8f:SvvcNHe0Nyr:S>fW0WQ。NVsQzTvQN8fXW bvNf9(u0YVvcbDvyNCg)R(Wyr:SQk(WNSVvvQN0W:SS0R}Y_YvOb0OgqhgvD,gTRRR]t (Yang, 1999, _NSachs and Yang, 2001 ,{16z) NShgTvc[Nt (Yang and Ng, 1995, _N Sachs and Yang, 2001,,{8z) hfYVON[g:_poRRRONbNNvON[bcVS~NSV0FOv0R 20 N~+g-NVvR]QST1u8f:SNN?e^cvON:N;N?e^N0W4YvN)R(u[0WeDnvWe:_YFU(WP[gPQ。NTNVNS OYVvcbD6R^(uegObYVON[vwNCgvRNEQRS%c0000v9eieNwQgSgTklNv>yO;NINv$N*NW,gyrp?elCgRvNZQWeTVgONv/eM0WMO09hncb (Lardy, 1998) ve.sU_(W9eieNcgqNQTǖ]4ls^0ǖ]k06e0RёDnv4ls^Tk Vg(Wib _0 (Wg'Yvyr:Sm3W VgONc6RW~Nm0FO/fNTNT_v6R^ -NVvNTv?e^:ggS0We?e^KN(W~NmNgvS_opvzN0 y6R^vyr_/f6R^SvV[:gO;NINTP% ~NmSU。N6q/fyrCg6B。e_)RvvN(0000-NVv^:W[T9eigyr_/f:ON[?ey^Tllhf6R^SvV[:gO;NIN~l6B。vGPlQNmyTsWsvPŲbN。(W_eRg:ON[?ey^v`QN^:W[T9eivyr_0000;`~NN-NV1980NT1990t^NNNwvvX~He;NR_Re[=_vwYSU。4ls^ (sSN~pvklNeNb`Yv'`()T!jNevQS[TW]NS!j_ve:gOv>yO;NIN^:W~Nm/fkvL?eRCgTVgONN[S~nT/neSU。!j_!jNvN*NmTSO0*NaINNv>yO;NIN^:W~NmNTNpQyO;NINNTe(W-N.Y;uTONv~NV[@bgCgN!jNvD,g;NIN]NS!j_vSgv>yO;NIN _NNTeNNHeNUOD,g;NIN~vklNv>yO;NIN0 (W!jNv。oR=。N_ -NVv>yO;NINe!j__NO1Y%ckY(W1930T1950t^N[vD,g;NIN]NSbRv!jNKN_ T_>yO;NINe20N~+g1Y%N7h0000[-NV9eivwYagNTcRRv bNsQe-NV9eivY[p000HQNN-NVN[[-NVSU。~He0O(KQeT (Sachs and Woo,1999) cQ-NVvX~Hev^NkvQNNN~NmX~He}YN[N(WSvNASt^WeRR[W6RbTQSXV{euNNk*N^:W~Nm^8^0WX19861994t^c-pNRs^Nte_-NVt^^NGWGDPXs(W5.66.8%KNvQNNNV[(W19651990t^fve_NhsQT7hufvc-pNRs^Nte_vt^^NGWGDPXsSb/n5.8V7.4eRaW7.4S~n6.3pS<。4.7legN4.5lV4.60SY(W-NVTetQ]NS~NmSOYS~nKNNGWw[6eeQ]N(WR'Y0000-NVv[e~_N0Ow[Xs0b (Lardy, 1998) cQ[eDe。0OXs12ŲNN-NVf[OYW~ (0~Nmf[mo`b01999t^5g15e1Hr) :N[eDe0OXs23Ųb (Lardy, 1998) _NcON-NV?e^EeawsQeVgLOW^TVgON"RrQDvnc00